ClonePartner vs. Import2: Which Data Migration Solution is Right for You?

Introduction: The High-Stakes Choice of a Data Migration Partner

Your entire company, your customer relationships, your support history, your internal knowledge, lives inside your software. Choosing to move that data from one platform to another is a high-stakes decision.

Get it right, and your team hits the ground running on a new, better platform with zero interruptions. Get it wrong, and you’re facing a nightmare of lost data, angry customers, broken workflows, and a team that’s dead in the water for days, or even weeks.

As you’ve started your search, you’ve likely come across two very different approaches to solving this problem:

1. Automated, Self-Service Tools: These are platforms, like Import2, that give you a set of connectors and ask you to map your data and run the migration yourself.
2. Engineer-Led, Managed Services: These are "done-for-you" services, like ClonePartner, where a team of migration experts takes on the entire project, writes custom code, and delivers a 100% complete migration for you.

Both promise to get your data from Point A to Point B. But how they do it, and more importantly, what they can actually move, is fundamentally different.

This article isn't a fight. It's an honest, in-depth comparison to help you understand these two philosophies. Is a one-size-fits-all automated tool enough for your business? Or do you need a custom-built solution tailored to your specific needs?

Let's dive in.

The Core Difference: A "Standard Template" vs. a "Tailored Blueprint"

Before we get into a feature-by-feature list, it’s critical to understand the one core difference that defines everything else.

The Automated Tool Approach (Import2)

Automated tools like Import2 are built on a "standard template" model. They work by creating a pre-defined map between two common platforms (for example, Zendesk and HubSpot). They know how to map a standard "ticket" field in Zendesk to a standard "ticket" field in HubSpot.

For a business with zero customization, this can work.

But your business isn't standard, is it?

What happens when your business has custom fields, like "Customer Tier" or "Product Line"? What about the dozens of triggers and automations you’ve spent years building? What about your knowledge base, your user profiles, or your complex ticket-to-company relationships?

This is where the standard template breaks. An automated tool can’t map what it doesn’t understand. It’s forced to either skip that data (data loss), drop it into a jumbled "notes" field (useless data), or stop the migration entirely, forcing you to manually clean up the mess.

The Engineer-Led Approach (ClonePartner)

At ClonePartner, we believe that every business's data structure is unique. A one-size-fits-all template is a gamble we’re not willing to take with your data.

Our process doesn't start with a "start" button. It starts with a conversation.

We operate on a "tailored blueprint" model. Our expert migration engineers sit down with you to understand your specific data and your specific workflows. Then, we write custom scripts to create a unique migration plan that maps 100% of your business logic.

• That "Customer Tier" field? We'll map it perfectly to the "Service Level" field in your new platform.
• Those 50+ automation rules? We’ll analyze and rebuild them.
• That custom-built internal tool? We'll write a new connector for it.

We’ve already helped hundreds of SaaS teams turn complex, "impossible" migrations into "that was easy" moments. We’ve successfully completed over 750+ custom data migrations, from a few thousand records to tens of millions. This approach is the only way to guarantee 100% accuracy and zero data loss.

At-a-Glance: ClonePartner vs. Import2

This table breaks down the fundamental differences in approach.

A Detailed Breakdown: Why These Differences Matter for Your Business

Let's go beyond the checklist. Here is what those feature differences actually mean for your team on migration day.

1. Data Completeness: Moving Your Entire Business, Not Just Parts of It

The single biggest complaint after a self-service migration is, "Where is the rest of our data?"

• Custom Objects & Workflows: Your business logic lives in your custom objects and automation rules. This is what makes your service unique. Import2's model is not designed to handle this complexity; it simply doesn't support the migration of custom objects, triggers, or macros. This means that on Day 1, your new platform is "dumb", all the intelligence you built is gone.
• User Data: Import2 does not migrate users. This is a critical gap. Without user data, you lose all historical context. Who was this ticket assigned to? Which agent solved the most issues? An engineer-led approach from ClonePartner ensures all users, agents, and groups are migrated with their relationships intact.
• Data Sources (like CSV): What if your data isn't in a nice, neat API? What if it's in a massive CSV export or an old SQL database? Automated tools can't handle this. ClonePartner can. We can take data from multiple, messy sources (CSVs, databases, multiple old help desks) and consolidate it all into one, clean, organized system.

The Bottom Line: A migration that only moves 80% of your data is a failed migration. ClonePartner is designed to move 100%, the standard fields, the custom fields, the workflows, the users, and everything in between.

2. Platform Support: "Unlimited" vs. "Limited"

Import2's library supports around 30 common platforms. If you are moving between two of those platforms and have no custom data, it might be an option.

But what happens when you’re not? What if you're moving from an on-premise system? Or a custom-built internal tool? Or a niche platform that isn't on their short list? You're stuck.

ClonePartner’s library starts with over 500+ integrations. But honestly, that number is just a starting point. Our real value is that we are platform-agnostic. If a connector for your tool doesn't exist, our engineering team will build one for you. This "unlimited" flexibility means we’ve never had to tell a client, "Sorry, we can't connect to that."

3. Security & Trust: The Non-Negotiable "Dealbreaker"

This is, in our opinion, the most critical differentiator. When you migrate data, you are giving a third party the keys to your entire kingdom, all your customer PII, all your internal conversations, all your sensitive data.

This is not an area to "just trust" someone. It's an area that demands proof.

At ClonePartner, we’ve built our infrastructure to meet the highest global standards for data security.

• We are fully compliant with AICPA SOC 2, a rigorous, independent audit of our security controls and processes.
• We are ISO 27001 certified, the international standard for information security management.
• We are fully GDPR and HIPAA compliant.

These certifications are your assurance that your data is being handled with bank-level security, encrypted in transit and at rest, and processed only by authorized personnel.

When evaluating Import2, we found a different picture.

• These critical security compliances (SOC 2, ISO 27001) are not listed on their site.
• During our own testing of the sign-up process, Google displayed a standard warning: "Google hasn’t verified this app," and advised not to use it.
• We also noted the platform asks for permissions (like email/username) that are not strictly necessary for an API-token-based connection.

The Bottom Line: For any business that handles customer data or operates in regulated industries like healthcare, finance, or B2B SaaS, the presence of audited security certifications like SOC 2 and ISO 27001 is a non-negotiable, mandatory requirement.

4. The Process & Experience: "Black Box" vs. "White Glove"

The experience of the migration is just as important as the outcome.

The "Do-it-Yourself" Experience: With a self-service tool like Import2, the burden of success is 100% on you. You have to configure the tool. You have to map the fields. You have to run the tests. And you have to validate the data.

This often feels like a "black box." You click the "Start" button and hope for the best. We've heard from users of automated tools that the screen can get stuck, leaving you to refresh for hours, never knowing if it's working, if it's failed, or when it will be done. If something goes wrong, you're filing a support ticket and waiting in a queue.

The "Done-for-You" ClonePartner Experience: Our service is designed to remove this anxiety. When you work with us, you are not buying a tool; you are hiring a dedicated engineering team.

Here’s what our process looks like:

1. Dedicated Engineer: From day one, you are assigned a dedicated migration engineer. This isn't a support agent; this is the expert personally writing the custom scripts for your project.
2. Kick-off & Mapping: We join a call with your team to review your data and map everything together, ensuring we understand your custom fields and workflows.
3. Test Migration: We don't "guess." We move a sample of your data (e.g., "let's hand-check 20 of your most complex tickets") and let you review it in the new platform. You don't approve it until it's 100% perfect.
4. Full Migration: We schedule the final, full migration to run at your convenience, even if that's Saturday at 2:00 AM, to ensure zero downtime or disruption for your team.
5. Post-Migration Support: We are on standby after the migration to ensure your team is happy and everything is working as expected.

With over 750+ custom migrations under our belt, we’ve refined this into a seamless process with the fastest possible turnaround time.

The Final Comparison: Price, Value, and Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

This is the most surprising part for most people. You would assume that a fully managed, engineer-led, custom-built migration service would be dramatically more expensive than a self-service tool.

Let's look at the numbers.

Import2's pricing is a transparent, tiered model based on record volume. Their "Enterprise" package, for example, is listed at $499 for up to 500,000 records.

This seems straightforward, but it's not the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO). To get the true cost, you must add:

• The cost of your own team's time (in hours or days) spent learning the tool, mapping fields, running tests, and manually verifying the data.
• The cost of data left behind (the business value of your custom fields and automations that can't be migrated).
• The cost of risk from potential security gaps or data loss.

These hidden expenses, the "Total Cost of Ownership", are often the most significant drain on a project. (We've written a detailed analysis on this topic, which you can read here: In-House vs. Outsourced Data Migration: A Realistic Cost & Risk Analysis).

ClonePartner's pricing is a custom quote. We provide our full, white-glove, engineer-led migration service at a price point that is often competitive to that of automated tools.

When you get a quote from us, it's one flat fee. It includes the engineer, the custom scripts, the testing, the validation, and the post-migration support. There are no hidden costs.

This presents a clear choice. Why would you pay a premium price for a limited, do-it-yourself tool, with all the associated risks, security concerns, and hidden time-sinks, when you can have a dedicated team of experts build a 100% custom, secure, and complete migration for you at a similar cost?

Conclusion: Who Is Import2 For, and Who Is ClonePartner For?

To be fair, an automated tool like Import2 can be a choice for a very specific user.

You might consider Import2 if:

• You are a solopreneur or a very small business.
• You have zero custom data fields or automations.
• You are migrating between two of the ~30 platforms they support.
• Your data is not sensitive, and you are not subject to compliance regulations like SOC 2, GDPR, or HIPAA.

ClonePartner is the partner for any professional, growing, or enterprise-level business that:

• Relies on custom data fields, objects, and workflows.
• Needs to migrate 100% of their data, including users, triggers, and macros.
• Is migrating from a niche, custom-built, or on-premise platform
• You also need to build custom integrations for your new platform.
• Treats data security and compliance (SOC 2, ISO 27001) as a top priority.
• Wants a guaranteed, 100% accurate migration without the headache, risk, or manual labor.

Your data is the lifeblood of your company. Don't gamble with it.

If you're ready for a migration that "just works," talk to one of our engineers today. We'll give you a free, custom-built migration plan and show you just how easy it can be.

Your "That Was Easy" Moment is One Click Away

Don't let the fear of a complex data migration stop you from upgrading your tools. Stop worrying about the "how" and let our expert engineers handle the entire process for you.

Talk to a Migration Expert Today and get a free, no-obligation strategy session and a custom-built plan for your project.